The first unit of the Villa Monterey Colony went up in 1961, and 180 houses sold in six months. The City of Scottsdale's historic district report calls it the first successful townhome project in Arizona. By 1969 Scottsdale had nearly 50 townhouse developments, and builders such as Dell Trailor and Hallcraft Homes kept adding more through the 1970s.
That building boom is about 50 years old now, and it shapes almost every condo search in 85251 today. A buyer touring Old Town condos is really choosing between two markets that share a ZIP code. In one, the price of a unit depends heavily on the age of the complex and the state of its association's finances.
One ZIP Code, Two Price Tags
Phoenix REALTORS' October 2026 Local Market Update for 85251 puts the year-to-date median townhouse and condo sale price through October at $400,400. That's down 4.7% from the same stretch of 2025. The year-to-date average sale price was $756,179.
When the average is almost double the median, a smaller group of high-priced sales is pulling the average up while most sales close well below it. Old Town has both kinds of building. At the newer end is ENVY Residences, an eight-story, 89-condominium building at 4424 N. 75th St. from Deco Communities. Its announcement described three underground parking levels, a 4,000-square-foot fitness space and a private owners' club. City permit records show ENVY's last condo unit built out in 2017, and Optima Camelview Village was permitted in phases from 2005 through 2011. At the older end are 1960s complexes like Golden Keys at 61st Street and Pinchot, a 1964 townhome subdivision built around a designed poolhouse and marketed at the time as an affordable way into condominium living.
So a single "Old Town condo price" doesn't describe what most units sell for. The median is closer to what a typical buyer pays. The average mostly tells you that luxury buildings exist.
Where the Older Stock Came From
Old Town and south Scottsdale didn't end up with so many aging townhouse and condo complexes by accident. According to the city's historic report, after Scottsdale adopted its 1974 Indian Bend Wash greenbelt plan, many multifamily and townhouse developments were approved on 736 acres of private land along the wash. Between 1970 and 1980, roughly 20,000 dwelling units were also approved as parts of large mixed-use projects, which made land for townhouses easier to come by.
The same report describes a citywide survey that counted 5,871 townhouses across 56 complexes. Villa Monterey's first seven plats alone were built between 1961 and 1969 and hold 758 houses. Much of that housing came out of a single era of planning, so a large share of it is reaching the age when expensive repairs come due.
Why the Age of a Complex Shows Up in the Price Now
Cromford Report senior housing analyst Tina Tamboer gave a blunt reading of the Valley condo market in a Tempe Tribune report: "The condo market is just really frigid right now." She put the Valley's median condo price at about $305,000, near mid-2021 levels. Her biggest concern was "Aging stock is my number one," and she pointed to older complexes that need roofs and stucco after years of delayed maintenance.
In that same Tempe Tribune report, she explained how the problems feed each other. An association without enough reserves may have to levy assessments on owners. Owners who can't pay may have to sell, which adds units to a market where buyers already hold the upper hand. Meanwhile, lenders look at the building's condition and the association's finances before they approve a mortgage. A buyer can love a unit and still struggle to finance it if the complex doesn't meet the lender's standards. Tamboer said newer communities, and those close to jobs and freeways, generally hold up better.
That helps explain a longer-run figure. Scottsdale Progress reported a Cromford analysis showing that over the three years it covered, median sale price per square foot rose 1.7% in 85251. The same analysis showed 17.5% in 85254 and 14.7% in 85258. Those figures include every property type, and Tamboer cautioned that ZIP codes don't line up exactly with city boundaries and that changes in which homes sold can move a median. In a ZIP code with this much older attached housing, a flat three-year line fits a market where buyers are discounting the cost of the building along with the unit.
How 85251 Compares With Its Neighbors
October 2026 townhouse and condo figures from Phoenix REALTORS, current as of Nov. 3, 2026:
| October 2026, townhouse/condo | 85251 | 85250 | 85257 | Scottsdale overall |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Median sale price, October | $383,900 | $475,000 | $193,500 | $485,000 |
| Median sale price, year to date | $400,400 | $490,750 | $268,250 | $495,000 |
| Months of supply | 8.3 | 5.7 | 9.8 | 6.6 |
| Median days on market | 95 | 54 | 175 | 78 |
| Percent of list price received | 96.2% | 96.8% | 93.1% | 96.6% |
| Pending sales | 20 | 8 | 3 | 89 |
The 85251 October median of $383,900 was up 30.1% from October 2025. That came from only 31 closings, and the report warns that small samples can swing monthly percentages hard. The year-to-date median is the better guide.
The more useful comparison is inside 85251. In October 2026, single-family homes in the ZIP had 5.4 months of supply. Townhouses and condos had 8.3. Detached homes and attached homes in the same streets, a few blocks apart, are moving at different speeds. Townhouse and condo pending sales in 85251 fell to 20 in October from 42 a year earlier, while active listings held almost steady at 374, against 378 a year before. Half as many buyers went under contract with the same number of units on offer.
The citywide figure needs one caveat. Tamboer said Scottsdale's condo numbers looked comparatively healthy, but new townhouse construction can stay listed as under contract for a long time while the units are built, which makes demand look stronger than it is. The Scottsdale-wide townhouse and condo column in the table includes that effect, and the 85251 resale picture is cooler than the citywide line suggests.
What This Means at an Old Town Showing
In October 2026, 85251 townhouse and condo sellers received 96.2% of list price. Phoenix REALTORS notes that the figure doesn't count concessions or down-payment assistance. In the Tempe Tribune report, Tamboer said she expects some condo sellers to negotiate more aggressively late in the year, and that buyers who can get financing could find substantial room to negotiate.
Her practical advice for condo deals was to "talk to a lender and find out if they've done a loan in there," or to check whether any loan has closed in the complex in the last month or two. She said that shows whether lenders currently treat the development as financeable. For a buyer comparing two units at similar prices, that recent lending history often separates them more than the kitchen finishes do.
Single-family Scottsdale is in a different position. Scottsdale Progress reported a Cromford Market Index of 144.2 for Scottsdale on Oct. 15, the highest of the 18 Valley communities Cromford tracks, though down 9% from a month earlier. In the same report, Tamboer said Valley-wide condo prices were down 5% from a year earlier while single-family prices were up 1.3%. A buyer moving up from an Old Town condo to a house is selling into the cooler market and buying in the stronger one. That gap should go into the plan from the start.
If you're weighing a walkable address close to the Old Town Scottsdale Farmers Market, our Scottsdale neighborhood guide covers the wider area. This post is general market information, not financial or legal advice, so confirm financing and association details for any specific complex with your lender and the right professionals.
Logan Lewis can help you compare Old Town complexes on their age, recent lending history and what has sold nearby. If you own in 85251 and want to know where your unit sits between the $400,400 median and the luxury end of the market, start with a free home valuation.